APPENDIX J

Prepared for NICHD Workshop "Improving Data on Male Fertility and Family Formation" at the Urban Institute, Washington, D.C., January 16-17, 1997

CONSTRUCTS USED ON DATA COLLECTION

Table 1. How is Father Involvement Assessed In Large Data Sets: Summary of Father Involvement Categories by Data Set.

Data Set NLSY PSID MILC NSFH NCS BALT NHSCH PSYP HSB NELS NFVS SCCS SPC ADDH
Involvement Measures

Positive Involvement:

Presence/

Absence









X








X








X








X








X








X








X








-








X








X








X








X








X








X
Communication

Teaching

Monitoring

Thought Processes

Errands

Caregiving

Child Maint.

Shared Interests

Availability

Planning

Shared Act.

Providing

Affection

Protection

Emotional Supp.

X

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

X

-

X

-

-

-

-

X

X

X

X

-

X

-

-

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

X

-

-

X

X

X

X

-

X

-

-

X

-

X

X

X

-

X

-

X

X

-

-

X

-

-

X

-

-

-

X

-

X

-

-

-

-

-

X

-

-

X

-

X

X

X

-

X

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

X

-

-

-

-

-

-

X

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

X

-

-

-

X

X

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

X

X

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

X

-

-

-

X

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

X

X

X

-

-

X

-

-

X

-

-

-

X

-

-

-

X

X

-

-

-

-

-

X

-

X

-

X

-

X

X

X

X

-

-

-

-

-

X

-

X

X

X

-

X

Other Family

Process

- - - - - - - - - - - - - -


Negative Involvement:

Conflict

Harsh Punishment

Abuse

Non-payment







-

-

-

-







X

X

-

-







X

-

-

-







X

X

-

-







X

X

-

-







-

-

-

-







-

-

-

-







-

-

-

-







-

-

-

-







-

-

-

-







X

X

X

-







-

-

-

X







-

-

-

-







X

-

-

-

NLSY=National Longitudinal Survey of Youth; PSID=Panel Study of Income Dynamics, child Supplement (1997); MILC=Marital Instability Over the Life Course: NSFH=National Survey of Families and Households; NCS =National Survey of Children; BALT=Baltimore Study of Unplanned Teen Parenthood; NHSCH=National Health Interview Survey of Child Health; PSYP=Wisconsin Study of Premarital Sexuality Among Young People; HSB=High School and Beyond; NELS=National Education Longitudinal Study; NFVS=National Family Violence Study; SCCS=Stanford Child Custody Study; SPC=Survey of Parents and Children; ADDH=Add Health Survey

Table 2. National Longitudinal Study of Youth, 1979-1993

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence Live in household with father/step-father

Distance father lives from mother

Father alive

Year by year history (birth - age 18) of living with biological father/adoptive father

Communication Talk about sex
Teaching
Monitoring
Thought Processes
Errands
Caregiving
Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability Number of times father visits child; length of visits

Child see father(-figure) daily (children under 5 years)

Child see and spend time with father (-figure); how often (children 6 years and older)

Planning
Shared Activities How often with father(-figure) outdoors (children 6 years and older)
Providing
Affection
Protection
Supporting Emotionally
Negative Involvement:
Conflict
Harsh Punishment
Abuse
Non-Payment
Miscellaneous
General Comments Cohort of youth 14 to 21 years old in 1979

Table 3. Father Involvement, Child Development Supplement , PSID

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence Biological father still living; how far away does he live
Communication In past 12 months, how often child talk on telephone or receive a letter from father not in household

How often discuss with child: school activities; things child studies; child's experiences

Teaching How much schooling father hope child will complete; how much expect child will complete

In past week, how many time have you: grounded child; taken away TV or other privileges; taken away allowance; sent child to room

Agreement with attitudes about mother's/father's role in child rearing (e.g. essential that father spend time interacting and playing with children, mothers are naturally more sensitive caregivers than fathers are)

When did respondent take parenting classes

Degree of conflict between parents on child related issues (how child raised; spending money on children; time spent with children)

Question asking how involved the respondent's biological or adoptive father was in raising you: have another father figure; how much influence your father's involvement had on you in raising your children

Agreement with attitudes on 21 items regarding husband's/wive's role in family (e.g. impacts on children if mothers work, daycare for children)

Parent rating of most important things child needs to learn to prepare child for life

Monitoring 10 items related to hypothetical situation regarding child bringing home report card with grades/progress less than parent expected--what is likelihood parent would e.g., contact teacher or principal; talk with child; spend more time helping child

Are there many rules; are they strictly enforced

Set of nine questions with the following form: How often do you (set limits on child's time watching TV; set limits on what is watched; limit snacks; discuss rules with children)

How often know who child is with when child not home

How many of child's close friends do you know by sight and by first and last name

Thought Processes Set of 9 statements about how parent feels raising children (e.g., being parent harder than thought; feel trapped my responsibility as parent; would do better in life without my child)
Errands
Caregiving Set of 9 questions regarding which parent(s) actually does the child-related tasks (e.g., bathing child, buying clothes, selecting a pediatrician)
Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability In past 12 months, how often child see father; when last see father; how many day stay with father

In past year has father outside household taken child on vacation

In 1995, how many days child spend with you (father outside of household)

Participation in school activities (11 items), e.g. conference with teacher observed child's classroom, attend PTA-type meetings

Planning Agreement with 4 statements about rearing/educating children (e.g. parent should not question teacher's methods)

4 items regarding participation in child's schooling/program enrollment (e.g., obtain information about teacher, meet with teacher)

Set of 9 questions regarding which parent is responsible for planning the child-related task (e.g., bathing child, buying clothes, selecting a pediatrician)

Shared Activities How often read to child; take child to grocery; talk to child when busy

How often done the following (13 items) with child (e.g., wash or folded clothes, gone to store, worked or homework)

How often in past month have you: spent time in one of child's favorite activities; joked or played with child; talked about something child interested in

How often father outside household spend time with child in leisure activities; religious activities; talking, working on project, playing; school or other organized activities

Providing Financial help from father outside household in buying clothes, toys, presents; paying camp or lessons; paying dental or insured medical expenses; paying child's medical insurance
Affection In past week, how many times have you: praised child; shown physical attention (hug, kiss, stroke hair, etc.); told another adult something positive about child

In past month, how often have you hugged or shown physical affection; told child you loved him/her; told child appreciated something he/she did

Rate child's relationship with you

Protection To primarily make life better for child, has respondent ever: moved to another neighborhood; increased work hours; decreased work hours
Supporting Emotionally Father's influence in making decisions about things such as religion, education
Negative Involvement:
Conflict How much trouble has child been to bring up

Child does what parent tells her

Harsh Punishment When child angry, if child hit you would you (e.g., hit back; give time out); if child said "I hate you", or swear would you (e.g. ground; spank, ignore)

Attitude toward spanking if child seriously misbehaving

At what age start spanking; how many time spank child in past week

Abuse
Non-payment
Miscellaneous
General Comments In 1997, with funding from the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD), the PSID will collect information on 0-12 year old children from the children and their parents. The PSID is conducted at the Survey Research Center, Institute for Social Research, University of Michigan.

Different surveys used for primary caregiver (generally the mother), partner of the primary caregiver, and for fathers who live outside the target child's household. Most questions regarding father involvement repeated on all surveys.

Note: Table based on Questionnaires dated October, 1996.

Table 4. Marital Instability Over the Life Course, 1980-1988

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence Relationship to respondent (male respondent's applicable)

Children not living with respondent; distance lives from respondent

Communication Number of days since spoke to child not living in household
Teaching Able to handle children after divorce
Monitoring
Thought Processes
Errands
Caregiving
Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability
Planning
Shared Activities
Providing
Affection Variety of questions

Wished did not live with children; can handle living apart from children

Closeness to child from previous marriage; closeness of spouse's child from previous marriage

Satisfaction with children

Quality of relation with children

Attitude toward children leaving home; attitude toward children returning home

Protection
Supporting Emotionally
Negative Involvement:
Conflict Child gives respondent problems; child from previous marriage gives respondent problems; child from spouses previous marriage gives respondent problems

How much problem are stepchildren

Any children give more than usual problems

Harsh Punishment
Abuse
Non-Payment
Miscellaneous
General Comments Respondents: 821 males, 1212 females

3 waves

Table 5. National Survey of Families and Households, 1988

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence Household composition information

Distance father lives from child

Father still living

Communication In past year, how often child talk/get letter from father (not in household)

Time with child having private talks

Teaching How often respondent yells at child

Allows child to set rules

Expectations of children regarding spending money

Monitoring 5 questions about leaving child alone at various times (after school, overnight)

Know where child is when away from home

Restrict amount of TV; types of programs

Remind child to do chores

How important for child to follow family rules; to always do what respondent asks

Time spent at PTA/other school activities

Thought Processes Child easy/difficult to raise
Errands
Caregiving Number of hours per day take care of child
Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability In past year, how often child see father

Some questions on visitation agreement

Questions about time spent: at religious youth groups; at team sports/youth athletic clubs; at community youth groups

Planning
Shared Activities Different questions for children in different age groups, including children over 18 years

e.g., time spent with child on outing away from home; playing together at home; with reading or homework; eating breakfast with child; eating lunch with child

Providing Help child (over 18 years) with: transportation; home/car repairs; housework
Affection How often respondent praises child

How often respondent hugs/cuddles child

Rate relationship with each child (very poor--excellent)

How much influence respondent has on child

Number of days had good time with child

Protection
Supporting Emotionally Help child (over 18 years) with advice/moral support
Negative Involvement:
Conflict How often argue or fight with child last month

How handled disagreement: keep opinions to self; discuss calmly; shout; hit/throw things

How many arguments led to: becoming physical; respondent or child hitting/shoving/throwing things; respondent or child getting cut/bruised/injured

Series of 10 questions about how many times in last year respondent argued or disagreed with child on variety of items, e.g., with how she/he dresses; about her/his friends; about her/his sexual behavior

Harsh Punishment How often respondent slaps/spanks child
Abuse
Non-Payment
Miscellaneous Section of 8 questions about raising step-children (e.g. easier to love than own children; easier to discipline than own children)
General Comments Both male and female respondents

Table 6. National Survey of Children

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence Type of father (in household)

Biological father dead or living elsewhere

Communication
Teaching When child good, dad: takes child out someplace; buys special things C

When child bad, dad: makes fun of child; yells at child; acts if no love C

When child bad: dad talks to child; sends to room; takes away privileges C

Father is firm C

Monitoring Who attends school conference

Father gives clear and consistent rules C

Father wants to know what child is doing C

Thought Processes
Errands
Caregiving Questions asked to child about who makes decisions about child's: clothes; friends; how late child can stay out; amount TV child can watch; religious training; seeing homework is done; discipline

Questions asked to parent about who makes decisions about child's clothes; how child spends money; friends; how late child can stay out; how much allowance child gets; how much TV child can watch; child's religious training

Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability Father spend enough time with you (asked in all waves) C
Planning
Shared Activities
Providing
Affection When child good: dad says he's pleased; kisses/hugs C

Amount of affection from dad C

How close feel to your father; to your stepfather C

Rate father/youth relationship P

Want to be like father as adult C

Father loves child/ interested in child C

Protection
Supporting Emotionally Father trusts even when not around C

Father encourages to do best C

Father appreciates child's accomplishments C

Negative Involvement:
Conflict How much child argue with father C
Harsh Punishment When child bad, dad spanks/slaps; ever hurt by dad spank/slap C
Abuse
Non-Payment
Miscellaneous Asks a lot of same questions to child about father and about outside parent
General Comments 3 waves

Parent respondent: 1366=mom/mom substitute, 57=dad/dad substitute

Note:

P Parent responded to question

C Child responded to question

Table 7. 1966-72 Baltimore Study of Unplanned Teen Parenthood

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence Marital Status (all waves)

Marry baby's father

Why some/no chance to marry baby's father in future

Does father of child currently live in household

Communication
Teaching
Monitoring
Thought Processes
Errands
Caregiving Is father satisfied/would change how raise child; respondent or father make important decisions about child
Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability Baby's father visits baby

Does father spend time with child; number of hours father (step) spent weekly; respondent feel father (step) spends enough time with child; why father finds difficult to spend enough time; children spend time with father in past year; frequency children/father spend time together

Planning
Shared Activities Frequency child plays with father
Providing Does father pay for child expenses; how much; non-financial assistance from father of child
Affection Father's enjoyment of child; child's enjoyment of father; how much does father enjoy play with child; how much does child enjoy play with father
Protection
Supporting Emotionally
Negative Involvement:
Conflict
Harsh Punishment
Abuse
Non-Payment
Miscellaneous Description of how child's father felt at pregnancy; number of children father wants
General Comments Four waves of interviews with 404 women who were pregnant (and under age 18) at the time of the first interview in 1966 and registered at the Sinai Hospital prenatal clinic in Baltimore

Table 8. National Health Interview Survey on Child Health, 1988

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence Type of family; identification of child's father figure in household; relationship of sample child to father figure in household

Has child ever lived with biological dad for at least 4 months; month/year last lived with biological father; duration since child last lived with biological father

Communication
Teaching
Monitoring
Thought Processes
Errands
Caregiving
Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability When (how often) does child see father
Planning
Shared Activities
Providing
Affection
Protection
Supporting Emotionally
Negative Involvement:
Conflict
Harsh Punishment
Abuse
Non-Payment
Miscellaneous
General Comments Information collected for 17,110 children 0-17 years. Respondent was child's mother 80% of time (biological mother=12,946, biological father=1,516).

Table 9. 1973 Madison, Wisconsin Study of Premarital Sexuality Among Young People: Student and

Non-student Samples

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence
Communication How much your father understands you

Following questions related to father's communication on sexual behavior/premarital sex:

Evaluate sex education from your father; father feel acceptable--fondle breasts; father feel acceptable--fondle genitals; father feel acceptable--sexual intercourse; source moral attitude (sex); source knowledge sex physiology; source information about sex mechanics; contraceptive knowledge; how father feel if you live with someone unmarried; how father think if you are unwed and pregnant; how father think if you impregnated a girl

Teaching
Monitoring
Thought Processes
Errands
Caregiving
Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability
Planning
Shared Activities
Providing
Affection How close are you to your father

Influence father have on your decision

How often father display affection toward you

Protection
Supporting Emotionally
Negative Involvement:
Conflict
Harsh Punishment
Abuse
Non-Payment
Miscellaneous
General Comments Identical surveys administered to two samples: 1)unmarried undergraduate students aged 16 to 29 years--432 males and 431 females; 2)non-students aged 18-23 who resided in Madison, Wisconsin but who were not students at the university--220 males and 293 females

Table 10. High School and Beyond, 1980-1983

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence Father or other male guardian in household
Communication
Teaching Father plans school program; father's opinion about plans after high school
Monitoring Father monitors school work
Thought Processes
Errands
Caregiving
Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability
Planning
Shared Activities
Providing
Affection
Protection
Supporting Emotionally
Negative Involvement:
Conflict
Harsh Punishment
Abuse
Non-Payment
Miscellaneous
General Comments Base survey and 3 follow-ups

2 cohorts: Sophomore, Senior

Table 11. National Education Longitudinal Study: 1988-1994

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence Father, Stepfather, or other adult male in household
Communication
Teaching How far wants child to go in school; plan high school program; opinion about what to do after high school
Monitoring Father home when child returns from school
Thought Processes
Errands
Caregiving
Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability
Planning
Shared Activities
Providing
Affection Get along with father
Protection
Supporting Emotionally
Negative Involvement:
Conflict
Harsh Punishment
Abuse
Non-Payment
Miscellaneous
General Comments Base year through 3rd follow-up

8th grade cohort

Table 12. National Family Violence Study, 1975 and 1985

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence Male head always present in relevant questions (respondent needs to be a male for questions to be applicable)
Communication
Teaching In past year, respondent ever (and number of times): discuss issue calmly with child; get information to back up side

This same set of questions are then asked with respect to how child deals with respondent.

Monitoring
Thought Processes
Errands
Caregiving
Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability
Planning
Shared Activities
Providing
Affection
Protection
Supporting Emotionally
Negative Involvement:
Conflict 19 questions about conflict resolution when disagreement occurred

e.g. When disagreement, parent ever: discuss issue calmly; stomped out of room; beat up child

This same set of questions are then asked with respect to how child deals with respondent

Harsh Punishment In past year husband use physical punishment on child; number of times used

Also asks if respondent's father used physical punishment; number of times used

Abuse In past year, respondent ever (and number of times) beat up child; kicked/bit/hit with fist; hit/tried to hit child with object; burned/scalded child; threatened child with knife/gun

This same set of question asked with respect to how child deals with respondent.

Non-Payment
Miscellaneous
General Comments Respondents include both males and females

1 referent child

Similar survey in 1975 and 1985

Table 13. Stanford Child Custody Study, 1984-1990

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence Child's residential custody (de facto)
Communication Variety of questions regarding talking to father on phone

How easy to chat with child

Teaching How child acts when corrected; child comply when asked to do something

Child easier to raise after divorce

Monitoring Who supervises homework

Keep track of where child is

Regular times for bed/meals at dad's; consistent with demands of child

Thought Processes
Errands
Caregiving Who is primary caretaker

Who shops for children's everyday clothes; takes care of checkups

Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability Many detailed questions

e.g., Number of overnights with father (last week; unscheduled; usual in two week period); amount of time spent with father in summer; amount of time child wants to spend with father

Questions related to the visitation schedule (when visitation occurs; father want to change schedule; child want to change schedule)

Factors affecting time spent with children (4 in wave 1, 6 in wave 2, 8 in wave 3), e.g., new relationship; new residence; dad lives too far away; no regular visitation hours

Planning
Shared Activities
Providing
Affection Involvement (high--low) with child before separation; since separation; currently

How is relationship with child

Patience with child (easy--difficult)

Protection
Supporting Emotionally
Negative Involvement:
Conflict
Harsh Punishment
Abuse
Non-Payment Impact of dad's missed child payments on relationship
Miscellaneous
General Comments 3 waves

Study of post-separation child custody arrangements in sample of 1,124 families in two California counties

Same question asked to mother and father

Table 14. 1990 Survey of Parents and Children

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence Biological father not in household; still living C
Communication
Teaching How often wish parent more strict

How much father (or male parent) makes you follow rules

Parent answered series of 15 hypothetical questions (e.g., Amount of discipline if child: did not turn in homework; got drunk; used drugs)

Monitoring Talk to teacher about school progress P

Parent answered whether attended PTA meeting/special school meeting in past year

Thought Processes
Errands
Caregiving
Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability Time Spent with father not living in householdP

Time spent with biological father (past 5 years; past year); enough time with C

Parent answered 4 questions, e.g., In past year worked with youth group/sports team/club

Planning
Shared Activities 10 questions about a variety of activities, e.g., attend religious services together; play sports games together P

How often father miss important events/activities; how often stepfather miss important events/activities P

Providing
Affection All questions asked to child

Relationship with respondent

Father special adult in life/cares about you; stepfather/foster father special adult in life/cares about you

Look up/admire/would like to be like father; look up/admire/would like to be like stepfather/foster father

Think father let you down; think stepfather/foster father let you down

Protection
Supporting Emotionally Father/biological father respects ideas/opinions
Negative Involvement:
Conflict
Harsh Punishment
Abuse
Non-Payment
Miscellaneous 3 questions asked to parent about involvement in child/parenting information group, e.g., attend class/talk about child rearing
General Comments Respondents: 611 male, 1127 females

Includes questions asked to parent and to child

Notes:

P Question asked to parent

C Question asked to child

Table 15. National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health, Wave 1

Involvement Measures Description
Positive Involvement:
Presence/Absence Know anything about biological father; he still living; how old were you when he died; did you ever live with him; how old were you when you last lived with him; how many years had you been living with him at that point

In what year did child most recently live with biological father

Ever a period of at least 6 months when child did not live with respondent; what age was child

Communication In last 12 months, how often talked to father (not in household) in person or on the telephone, or received a letter from him

In past 4 weeks, have you done the following with your biological father/adoptive father/stepfather/foster father/ etc.: talked about someone you're dating, or a party you went to; had a talk about a personal problem you were having; talked about other things you're doing in school

You are satisfied with the way your father and you communicate with each other

Respondent just does not understand child

It would embarrass child to talk to respondent about sex and birth control

Respondent talked with child about having sex and: negative impact if he got someone/she got pregnant; the dangers of STDs; neg impact on social life; moral issues of not having sex

How much respondent talk to child about birth control; about sex

Teaching In past 4 weeks, have you done the following with your father biological father/adoptive father/stepfather/foster father/ etc.: gone to a religious service or church-related event; talked about your school work or grades

On a scale of 1 to 5, how disappointed would resident father be if you did not graduate from college; if you did not graduate from high school

In past week, has respondent and child talked about child's school work or grades; about other things child is doing in school

What is most important item that child could be following high school

How disappointed would respondent be if child did not graduate from college

Child and respondent make decisions about child's life together

Respondent doesn't know enough about sex and birth control to talk to child about them; it would be difficult for respondent to explain these things to child; don't need to talk about these things since child will get information elsewhere; talking about this subject would encourage child to have sex

Monitoring How would your father feel about your having sex at this time in your life; about your having sexual intercourse with someone who was special to you and whom you knew well; about your using birth control at this time in your life

Respondent disapproves of child having sex at this time in child's life; would not mind child having sex with a steady friend; respondent recommended a specific method of birth control to child

Set of questions regarding child's best friend: has respondent met friend; know what school friend goes to; met this friend's parents; what kind of influence is friend

Similar set of questions regarding child's special friend (girlfriend/boyfriend)

How many parents of child's friends has respondent talked to in last 4 weeks

What time does child have to go to bed on week nights

Has respondent talked with any teacher about school work this school year

Thought Processes
Errands
Caregiving
Child-Related Maintenance
Shared Interests
Availability In last 12 months, how often have you stayed overnight with father (not in household)

How often is resident father at home: when you leave for school; when you return from school; when you go to bed

During school year, has respondent participated in school fund-raising or done volunteer for the school

Child interferes with respondent's activities

Planning
Shared Activities In past 4 weeks, have you done the following with your biological father/adoptive father/stepfather/foster father/ etc.: gone shopping; played a sport; gone to a movie, play, museum, or concert, or sports events; worked on a project for school
Providing In typical month, how much support does biological father pay for child
Affection How close do you feel to your biological father/adoptive father/stepfather/foster father/ etc.; how much do you think he cares about you

Most of the time, your father is warm and loving toward you

Overall, you are satisfied with your relationship with your father

How often do you get along well with child

Protection
Supporting Emotionally How often respondent feels can trust child
Negative Involvement:
Conflict In past 4 weeks, have you had a serious argument about your behavior with your biological father/adoptive father/stepfather/foster father/ etc.
Harsh Punishment
Abuse
Non-Payment
Miscellaneous Section of questions about twins (type of twins; how alike were they at age 8; when twins young was respondent often confused about which was which; how often was father confused)
General Comments Study was supported by grant from the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development

Information in table based on Codebooks developed by Carolina Population Center, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, February 1997